On March 31, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down a decision finding that immigrants have a right to be told by counsel that a guilty plea to a criminal charge may have consequences that would include deportation. If not informed, the lapse amounts to a violation of a criminal defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel. Justice John Paul Steven wrote for the majority with Justices Scalia and Thomas dissenting.

The majority of the Court found that the lack of information on a crucial topic like deportation did amount to ineffective counsel. Justice Stevens wrote, ‘‘Our long-standing Sixth Amendment precedents, the seriousness of the deportation as a consequence of a criminal plea, and the concomitant impact of deportation on families living lawfully in this country demand no less.’’

While Justice Alito and Chief Justice Roberts concurred with the majority, they felt it was incorrect to demand that criminal defense attorneys be liable for explanations regarding immigration law, an area outside their specialty.

Justices Scalia and Thomas disagreed with the majority of the Court, finding the serious immigration consequences of a poorly informed plea were outside the area protected by the Sixth Amendment. Justice Scalia wrote simply, ‘‘The Sixth Amendment guarantees the accused a lawyer ‘for his defense’ against a ‘criminal prosecution’ – not for sound advice about the collateral consequences of conviction.’’ 

The case has been returned to the Supreme Court of Kentucky to re-consider Padilla’s guilty plea. 

Related Resources:

  • Court: Defendants Entitled to Immigration Advice (New York Times)
  • U.S. Constitution: Sixth Amendment (FindLaw)
  • A SURPRISE FROM SCALIA:The Justice Votes For The Sixth Amendment, And For The Death Row Prisoner, In Ring V. Arizona (FindLaw’s Writ)
  • Immigration Overview (FindLaw)
  • Immigration: Removal & Deportation (provided by The Immigration Law Firm of New Orleans)
  • Constitutional Protections for the Criminal Defendant (provided by White & Hearne, L.L.P.)

You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help

Civil Rights

Block on Trump’s Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court

Criminal

Judges Can Release Secret Grand Jury Records

Politicians Can’t Block Voters on Facebook, Court Rules